Why so many brands sound like everyone else

Why do so many brands sound the same?

Try this. Open the websites of ten people who do what you do, in ten tabs. Read the first line of each homepage in a row.

I'll wait.

They blur, right? The same three benefit verbs. The same "I help X do Y" line. The same calm photo with a laptop. Nobody did anything wrong. They all just pulled from the same places.

The same templates. The same "how to write your About page" posts. The same few people at the top of the category, who everyone copies a little. And now the same AI tools, which do exactly what they're built to do: give you the likely answer. The likely answer is everyone's average. Ask a tool to write your homepage with nothing real to work from and it hands you the average, fluently, with your name on it.

That's the outside half of the problem. The inside half is harder to see.

The sameness you do to yourself

A lot of us were trained, long before we ran a business, to be easy to agree with. Soften the opinion before anyone pushes back. Add a qualifier. Ask "does that make sense?" after a point that made perfect sense.

So we edit. One founder I worked with rewrote every post three or four times before she published it. Anything too direct got softened, anything too opinionated got padded. By the time it went out, it was fine. It was also nothing like her in real life, and she couldn't understand why her engagement felt flat. Her audience could. The belief had leaked out of the language.

You can hear it happen in real time, too. I asked a founder what she believed about her industry that most people don't say out loud. She started with "it's totally financially driven," then, in the same breath, "not totally, I shouldn't say that." Then she backed it up anyway: in years of industry meetings she'd rarely heard anyone in the room talk about the people the work was actually for.

The first version had signal. The correction was the training talking. And her proof was the voice.

What does sounding the same cost you?

People see you. They just can't tell you apart from the next person.

That shows up in very practical ways:

• Referrals go vague. When someone wants to recommend you, they can't say what you do differently, so they don't, or they say it wrong.
• People pick the safe option. When ten offers sound the same, buyers go with the biggest name, the cheapest price or whoever they met first.
• Your message filters nobody. A message built to be liked by everyone keeps everyone slightly unsure, including the people who would have been perfect for you.
• Showing up gets heavy. Writing in a voice that isn't yours takes effort every single time.

Why posting more doesn't fix it

When nobody remembers you, the usual advice is more. More posts, more channels, more reach. Add AI and you can produce more than ever, in an afternoon.

But more of the same is still the same. If the message underneath isn't clear and isn't yours, every extra post just adds to the noise, yours and everyone else's. I've watched founders double their output and sound less like themselves every month, at exactly the same pace.

Tactics get copied fast. Your voice doesn't. So that's where the work goes.

How do you make your brand sound like you again?

1. Name what makes you different. Start with a question: what do you believe about your work that most people in your field don't say out loud? Write the sharp version. It's often the one you'd only say to a friend.

2. Keep the spine, adjust the delivery. One expert saw her point of view written down sharply for the first time and flinched. Too combative, she said, her buyers would get their backs up. She had a point about the tone. But the belief itself is the spine, and it stays at full strength. You can soften how you say it as much as you like. Just don't soften what you mean.

3. Find your register. One founder described hers to me almost word for word: bold in the ideas, subtle in the delivery, so people go "huh," and then they listen. Once your register has a name, every piece you write has a test it can pass or fail.

4. Stop editing yourself out. Your voice is already there, in the drafts you delete and the thoughts you soften before posting. Everyone talks about finding your voice. Mostly, it's about no longer removing it.

5. Repeat it. This is the part founders hate. Once your sentence is clear, you'll feel like you're saying the same thing over and over. You are, and that's the job. The rule I teach is ten pieces of contact for every one that actually gets noticed. Keep the core and change the story around it: new example, new angle, same true thing. That's how a position gets attached to a name. (Chapter 13 of my book is all about this.)

A quick test before you publish anything

Take your last five posts or your homepage and ask: could someone else in my field drop this under their own name, and nobody would notice?

If the answer is yes, go back to step one. A better hook won't change it.

And if you want the long version of where this starts, read A brand should sound like the woman behind it. For what AI does to all of this, read If AI can fake you.

Where to start this week

• Do the ten-tabs exercise on your own category. Then read your own homepage last. Does it blur in?
• Find one sentence you softened this month. Write the version you actually meant. Say it out loud.
• Pick one idea and say it three times this month, three different ways. Watch who starts repeating it back.

When you're ready to name the difference properly, that's the brand build I do at OG Solutions. → Brand development

FAQ